Skip to main content
Version: 3.4.20 (unreleased)

Slope Stability: Method

Scope. This page is the methodological companion to the Slope Stability user guide. The guide covers the dialog, the stereonet properties and the workflow; this page states what each test computes, with the formulas and the default values, so that a result can be understood, reported and reproduced.

Abstract​

A kinematic analysis asks whether the geometry of a slope and of its discontinuities lets a block move: whether a plane is steep enough to slide on and daylights in the face, whether two planes form a wedge whose line of intersection does, whether steep planes dipping into the face let the rock between them bend over, and whether columns bounded by two sets lean far enough out of the face to fall. VRGS tests four failure modes — planar sliding, wedge sliding (Markland, 1972, with Hocking's 1976 refinement), flexural toppling (Goodman & Bray, 1976) and direct toppling (Hudson & Harrison, 1997). Every test is a sign test on unit vectors, so it holds for any face orientation, overhangs included. A mode is scored as the percentage of a discontinuity set's planes, or of the lines where two sets' planes meet, that are critical. On a mesh or point cloud the slope face is fitted around every point at a chosen scale and each point reads its percentages from a table of face orientations; on the stereonet one face is analysed and its construction and critical zones are drawn, as Dips draws them. The planes can be weighted for the bias of sampling them from the face, and each point can lean on the planes measured near it. Beyond the kinematic screen, VRGS works out deterministic limit-equilibrium factors of safety on each set's mean plane — planar sliding after Hoek & Bray (1981), wedges by the vector method, and block toppling after Goodman & Bray (1976) — with the slope height taken from the local relief of the model.

1. Introduction​

Structurally controlled failures of rock slopes are governed first by geometry. A block can slide on a plane only if the plane is steeper than its friction angle and is cut by the slope face, so that the block is free to move out of it; a wedge can slide only if the line along which its two planes meet does the same; a stack of steep layers dipping into the slope can topple only if the layers can slip past each other. These conditions are tested on a stereonet by the classical construction (Markland, 1972; Hoek & Bray, 1981; Goodman, 1980; Wyllie & Mah, 2004), and a result is usually reported as the percentage of the measured discontinuities, or of their intersections, that plot in a critical zone.

That result belongs to one slope face. On a photogrammetric or lidar model the face changes from place to place — a bench, a buttress, a gully, an overhang — and a single stereonet cannot say where along the outcrop a set becomes critical. VRGS therefore uses the same tests two ways:

  1. As maps. The slope face is fitted around every point of a mesh or point cloud at a scale the user chooses, and the percentage critical for each mode is written as an attribute layer, with a classification into the dominant mode.
  2. On the stereonet. For one face the user sets, the construction and the critical zones are drawn over the plotted planes, with the percentages set by set and pair by pair.

Both use the same tests, sets and percentages, so the key of the stereonet and the layers of the map agree for a face of the same orientation.

The kinematic analysis says where the geometry permits a mode of failure; it knows nothing of cohesion, water pressure, block size, persistence or spacing, and a critical percentage is not a probability of failure or a factor of safety. The factors of safety of §9 add the weight, strength, water and seismic load of a block on each set's mean plane.

2. Conventions and notation​

The frame is x east, y grid north, z up; angles are in degrees, and a direction is measured clockwise from grid north. The unit vector with dip δ\delta towards direction α\alpha is

n(δ,α)=(sin⁡δsin⁡α, sin⁡δcos⁡α, cos⁡δ).\mathbf n(\delta,\alpha) = (\sin\delta\sin\alpha,\ \sin\delta\cos\alpha,\ \cos\delta).
  • A discontinuity plane has dip δ∈[0∘,90∘]\delta\in[0^\circ,90^\circ] and dip direction α\alpha. Its upward normal is n=n(δ,α)\mathbf n = \mathbf n(\delta,\alpha), its horizontal dip direction h^=(sin⁡α,cos⁡α,0)\hat{\mathbf h} = (\sin\alpha,\cos\alpha,0) and its down-dip vector d=cos⁡δ h^−sin⁡δ z^\mathbf d = \cos\delta\,\hat{\mathbf h} - \sin\delta\,\hat{\mathbf z}. Its lower-hemisphere pole p=−n\mathbf p = -\mathbf n plunges 90∘−δ90^\circ-\delta in the direction opposite the dip. A vertical plane (δ=90∘\delta = 90^\circ) dips both ways, and both senses of h^\hat{\mathbf h} are tried wherever a test uses the dip direction.
  • The slope face has dip ψf∈[0∘,180∘]\psi_f\in[0^\circ,180^\circ] and dip direction αf\alpha_f, the direction it looks. Its outward normal is f=n(ψf,αf)\mathbf f = \mathbf n(\psi_f,\alpha_f) and its horizontal direction h^f=(sin⁡αf,cos⁡αf,0)\hat{\mathbf h}_f = (\sin\alpha_f,\cos\alpha_f,0). A face dipping more than 90∘90^\circ overhangs, and its outward normal points down.
  • A line — here always a line of intersection of two planes — is the downward unit vector l\mathbf l, with trend τ\tau, plunge β\beta (so −lz=sin⁡β-l_z = \sin\beta) and horizontal direction h^l\hat{\mathbf h}_l.
  • Parameters: the friction angle ϕ\phi of the discontinuities and three lateral limits, λp\lambda_p for planar sliding (default 20∘20^\circ), λt\lambda_t for flexural toppling (30∘30^\circ) and λd\lambda_d for direct toppling (20∘20^\circ). A set with a joint strength of its own has its own ϕ\phi (§4.1); a test on a plane uses its set's, and a test on a line of intersection the lower of its two sets'.

Two horizontal directions are within λ\lambda of each other when a^⋅b^≥cos⁡λ\hat{\mathbf a}\cdot\hat{\mathbf b}\ge\cos\lambda. Comparing vectors rather than differences of angles means dip directions of 359∘359^\circ and 1∘1^\circ are 2∘2^\circ apart, with no special case at north. A level face (ψf=0∘\psi_f = 0^\circ or 180∘180^\circ) looks no way; the tests that need its direction are then never critical.

3. The failure modes​

3.1 Planar sliding​

A plane is critical for planar sliding (Hoek & Bray, 1981) when all three hold:

  1. it is steeper than the friction angle, δ>ϕ\delta > \phi;
  2. its dip direction is within the lateral limit of the face's, h^⋅h^f≥cos⁡λp\hat{\mathbf h}\cdot\hat{\mathbf h}_f \ge \cos\lambda_p;
  3. it daylights: its down-dip vector points out of the face, d⋅f>0\mathbf d\cdot\mathbf f > 0.

For a face dipping less than 90∘90^\circ the third condition is the familiar apparent-dip test: with Δ\Delta the angle between the two dip directions,

d⋅f=cos⁡δ sin⁡ψfcos⁡Δ−sin⁡δcos⁡ψf>0  ⟺  tan⁡δ<tan⁡ψfcos⁡Δ,\mathbf d\cdot\mathbf f = \cos\delta\,\sin\psi_f\cos\Delta - \sin\delta\cos\psi_f > 0 \iff \tan\delta < \tan\psi_f\cos\Delta ,

that is, the plane is flatter than the face in its own dip direction. Under an overhang cos⁡ψf<0\cos\psi_f < 0, and every plane dipping out of the face within the lateral limit daylights; a vertical plane daylights only there.

3.2 Wedge sliding​

Two planes with normals na\mathbf n_a and nb\mathbf n_b meet along

l=±na×nb∥na×nb∥,\mathbf l = \pm\frac{\mathbf n_a\times\mathbf n_b}{\lVert\mathbf n_a\times\mathbf n_b\rVert},

taken downward. ∥na×nb∥\lVert\mathbf n_a\times\mathbf n_b\rVert is the sine of the angle between the planes, and planes closer to parallel than the minimum wedge angle, 10∘10^\circ by default and yours to set, form no wedge: their line is too poorly defined to use. Lines are formed only between planes of two different sets.

Markland's test (Markland, 1972): the line is critical when it plunges more steeply than the friction angle and daylights,

β>ϕandl⋅f>0.\beta > \phi \quad\text{and}\quad \mathbf l\cdot\mathbf f > 0 .

There is no lateral limit: the two planes confine the block to the line.

Hocking's refinement (Hocking, 1976). A block that passes Markland's test does not always slide along its line. When the dip direction of one of the planes lies between the trend of the line and the direction the face looks, the block slides down that plane alone and lifts off the other. With xx the signed angle from τ\tau to αf\alpha_f and dad_a the signed angle from τ\tau to αa\alpha_a, both in (−180∘,180∘](-180^\circ,180^\circ], plane aa lies between when

da≠0,sign⁡da=sign⁡x,∣da∣<∣x∣,d_a \ne 0,\qquad \operatorname{sign} d_a = \operatorname{sign} x,\qquad \lvert d_a\rvert < \lvert x\rvert ,

and likewise for plane bb. When the face or the line is vertical, or a plane is level, nothing lies between and the block slides along the line. Either way the block is free to move, so a wedge counts when its line passes Markland's test, on the maps and in the stereonet's Wedge column. Hocking's test says only how it slides; the stereonet reports the blocks that slide on one plane separately (below).

One-plane sliding (Dips' secondary zone). A wedge whose line is too flat to slide along can still slide on one of its planes. VRGS counts a line in this zone when

β≤ϕ,l⋅f>0,l⋅nϕ<0,\beta \le \phi,\qquad \mathbf l\cdot\mathbf f > 0,\qquad \mathbf l\cdot\mathbf n_\phi < 0,

where nϕ=n(ϕ,αf)\mathbf n_\phi = \mathbf n(\phi,\alpha_f) is the upward normal of the friction plane, the plane dipping at the friction angle towards the face: the line daylights and lies below that plane. It is counted as sliding on one plane when one of its two planes is steeper than ϕ\phi and daylights (§3.1 without the lateral limit). Together with the Markland-critical lines that Hocking's test sends down one plane, which the Wedge column counts as well, these make the 1 plane column of the stereonet key.

3.3 Flexural toppling​

Steep layers dipping into a slope topple by bending when they can slip past each other. Goodman (1980), after Goodman & Bray (1976), states the condition for a plane dipping straight into the face as

(90∘−δ)+ϕ<ψf,(90^\circ-\delta) + \phi < \psi_f ,

within a lateral limit of straight in. VRGS applies it as Dips does, with the slip-limit plane: the plane dipping at σ=ψf−ϕ\sigma = \psi_f - \phi towards the face, with upward normal s=n(σ,αf)\mathbf s = \mathbf n(\sigma,\alpha_f). A plane is critical when σ>0\sigma > 0, its pole trends within the lateral limit of the face direction, −h^⋅h^f≥cos⁡λt-\hat{\mathbf h}\cdot\hat{\mathbf h}_f \ge \cos\lambda_t (the plane dips into the face within λt\lambda_t of straight in), and its pole lies below the slip-limit plane:

p⋅s=sin⁡δsin⁡σcos⁡Δ−cos⁡δcos⁡σ>0,\mathbf p\cdot\mathbf s = \sin\delta\sin\sigma\cos\Delta - \cos\delta\cos\sigma > 0 ,

with Δ\Delta the angle between the pole's trend and αf\alpha_f. Straight into the face (Δ=0\Delta = 0) this is −cos⁡(δ+σ)>0-\cos(\delta+\sigma) > 0, which is Goodman's condition. To the side it reads tan⁡(90∘−δ)<tan⁡σcos⁡Δ\tan(90^\circ-\delta) < \tan\sigma\cos\Delta: the pole must plunge less than the slip-limit plane's apparent dip in its direction, which is stricter than comparing the pole's plunge with σ\sigma. On the stereonet the critical poles lie between the slip-limit plane's great circle and the primitive, within the lateral limits.

3.4 Direct toppling​

Direct (block) toppling needs columns and a base (Hudson & Harrison, 1997). The columns are bounded by two sets whose line of intersection plunges steeply into the slope, so the columns lean out of the face; the base is a plane too gentle for the columns to slide on. VRGS uses the zones of Dips:

  • Zones 1 and 2 — direct toppling. A line of two sets' planes is critical when it trends into the slope within the lateral limit of straight in, and lies no further from vertical than the face dip:

    h^l⋅(−h^f)≥cos⁡λdand90∘−β≤ψf    (i.e. −lz≥cos⁡ψf).\hat{\mathbf h}_l\cdot(-\hat{\mathbf h}_f) \ge \cos\lambda_d \quad\text{and}\quad 90^\circ-\beta \le \psi_f \;\;(\text{i.e. } -l_z \ge \cos\psi_f).

    A vertical line leans no way and passes the lateral test. Under an overhang every line within the lateral limit passes the second test.

  • Zone 3 — oblique toppling. A line within the friction angle of vertical that leans into the slope but outside the lateral limit: 90∘−β<ϕ90^\circ-\beta < \phi and 0<h^l⋅(−h^f)<cos⁡λd0 < \hat{\mathbf h}_l\cdot(-\hat{\mathbf h}_f) < \cos\lambda_d.

  • Base planes. A plane that can be the base of the columns without sliding: it dips more gently than the friction angle, δ<ϕ\delta < \phi, and either dips out of the slope, h^⋅h^f>0\hat{\mathbf h}\cdot\hat{\mathbf h}_f > 0, or is level. On the net the pole of such a plane lies within ϕ\phi of the centre on the side away from the face, which is where the zones above lie: inside the lateral limits it is in the direct-toppling zone (Dips' zone 2) whenever ϕ≤ψf\phi \le \psi_f, and outside them in the oblique zone.

The Direct Toppling map layer holds the percentage of lines in zones 1 and 2. Oblique toppling and base planes are reported on the stereonet.

4. Discontinuity sets and percentages​

4.1 Sets​

A set is either the planes tagged with one project Set, wherever they sit in the tree, or the planes directly in one orientation folder. The maps take the Sets and folders ticked in the dialog; the stereonet takes the plane interpretations it plots, grouped by folder or by Set as its Sets From says, whatever the folders are called. Lineations are left out, and on the stereonet so are faults, scanline fractures, polylines, DFN fractures and mesh poles.

The maps can also take the fracture sets of a DFN: the active fractures of its current realisation, each a plane with its centre as its position. A DFN set named like a project Set takes that Set's friction and strength.

Friction per set. A project Set with a joint strength of its own (Collections > Sets) is tested at its own friction angle: a Mohr-Coulomb set's ϕ\phi, or a Barton-Bandis set's secant angle at its reference normal stress σref\sigma_{ref}, ϕ=ϕr+JRC log⁡10(JCS/σref)\phi = \phi_r + \mathrm{JRC}\,\log_{10}(\mathrm{JCS}/\sigma_{ref}), no more than 70∘70^\circ. Cohesion plays no part in the kinematic tests. Every other set takes the analysis's friction angle.

Older versions of Auto-cluster copied the planes they clustered into folders below the one they read and left the originals there. A folder holding every plane of some folder below it — a copy being the same dip and dip direction in single precision and the same fitting circle — is therefore not a set by default: the dialog leaves it unticked the first time, and the stereonet leaves its poles out. Taken as a set, its planes would meet copies of their own set's in lines that no two sets form. One plane in common is not enough, since compass readings in whole degrees repeat by chance. When the chosen sets share planes anyway — a folder and a Set, say — the run warns how many.

Before testing, each set's plane normals are merged into bins 1∘1^\circ wide in polar angle and azimuth. A bin holds the weighted mean direction of its planes and their number, wbw_b — their total weight when the planes are weighted (§8) — so the cost of the tests does not grow with the number of measurements. Lines of intersection are formed from every pair of plane bins from two different sets, weighted by the number of plane pairs, wawbw_a w_b, and binned in the same way. When a pair of sets has more than 10610^6 pairs of plane bins, its planes are re-binned at 2∘2^\circ, 4∘4^\circ and 8∘8^\circ until it has fewer. The minimum wedge angle is tested per pair of bins, so two planes within a bin's width of it can fall on the wrong side.

4.2 Percentages​

For a set SS and a mode tested on planes, the percentage critical is

P(S)=100 ∑b∈S, b criticalwb∑b∈Swb,P(S) = 100\,\frac{\sum_{b\in S,\ b\ \text{critical}} w_b}{\sum_{b\in S} w_b},

and for a pair of sets (S,T)(S,T) and a mode tested on lines,

P(S,T)=100 ∑critical lineswawb∑all lineswawb,P(S,T) = 100\,\frac{\sum_{\text{critical lines}} w_a w_b}{\sum_{\text{all lines}} w_a w_b},

where the denominator counts every pair of planes that meets in a line, critical or not. A pair closer to parallel than the minimum wedge angle is on neither side, so raising the angle can move P(S,T)P(S,T) up or down. With weights (§8) the denominator is not a count, so the stereonet's N counts the pairs of planes themselves.

A map holds the highest percentage over the sets (pairs of sets), P=max⁡SP(S)P = \max_S P(S) or max⁡S,TP(S,T)\max_{S,T} P(S,T), so a set that is fully critical is not diluted by a set that never is. The stereonet lists every set (pair) and All: the critical share of every plane of every set, or of every line of every pair of sets, counted together. Lines between two planes of the same set are never formed, so they are not in All either.

4.3 Classification​

The Kinematic Mode layer takes, at every point, the mode with the highest percentage among those tested — planar sliding (1), wedge sliding (2), flexural toppling (3) or direct toppling (4), ties going to the earlier — or none (0) when that percentage is zero or below the classification threshold (default 10%).

5. The slope face at a scale​

On a mesh or point cloud the face is the local surface at the scale of the failures being assessed, the radius rr — not a triangle, and not the whole outcrop.

  1. Samples. The live points are merged into cubes of side r/8r/8. Each occupied cube is one sample at the mean position of its points, carrying the sum of their outward hints (below). The work then depends on the area and the radius rather than the point density.
  2. Plane fit. For every sample cc, the samples within rr are weighted by the biweight w=(1−d2/r2)2w = (1 - d^2/r^2)^2, which falls smoothly to zero at the radius so the face does not jump as samples cross it. The face normal is the eigenvector of the smallest eigenvalue of their weighted covariance. A sample with fewer than 6 neighbours, or whose neighbourhood is a line or a point (second eigenvalue under 10−910^{-9} of the first), gets no face.
  3. Outward sense. A fitted plane has two sides. The side is taken from the hints of the neighbourhood: on a mesh the area-weighted vertex normals, which follow the triangle winding; on a point cloud the camera-oriented normals of an SfM dense cloud (the Nx, Ny, Nz layers), which point back towards the cameras. With H\mathbf H the weighted sum of the hints and LL the weighted sum of their lengths, the normal is turned to agree with H\mathbf H when ∣n⋅H∣>0.1 L\lvert\mathbf n\cdot\mathbf H\rvert > 0.1\,L. Otherwise — no hints, or hints that disagree within the radius — the face is unsigned and is folded to look upward, so an overhang among them reads as a slope facing the other way. The dialog's flip option reverses the hints, for a mesh whose normals point into the rock.
  4. Every point takes the face of its cube, as a dip ψf∈[0∘,180∘]\psi_f\in[0^\circ,180^\circ] and a dip direction.

The suggested radius is 2% of the model's diagonal but no less than twenty point spacings; a radius under four point spacings is raised to four, so a cube holds about a point or more.

5.1 Scales​

The face can be fitted at up to four radii in one run: a single radius, and the bench, inter-ramp and overall scales of open-pit design, which start at the suggested radius and four and sixteen times it. Each scale is a run of its own, through every step that follows, and writes its own layers, named with the scale.

5.2 Local relief and planes within radius​

At the same cubes, VRGS gathers every cube whose centre lies within rr of a cube's centre — a sphere, not a vertical cylinder — and writes, for every point of the cube:

  • Local Relief, H=zmax−zminH = z_{max} - z_{min} over the points of those cubes: the height range of the surface within the radius, to within a cube's width. It is the slope height of the factors of safety (§9).
  • Planes Within Radius, the number of measured planes of the chosen sets whose position — the centre of the circle fitted to the plane's points, or else where the plane is drawn — lies within rr of the cube's centre. A plane in two chosen sets counts twice.

6. The table of face orientations​

Once the sets, the friction angle and the limits are fixed, every percentage depends on the face orientation alone. VRGS therefore evaluates them once per orientation on a regular grid — face dip from 0∘0^\circ to 180∘180^\circ (both ends included) by dip direction from 0∘0^\circ to 360∘360^\circ (wrapping), 1∘1^\circ apart — and every point reads its face from the table by bilinear interpolation between the four nodes around it. Hocking's test and the lateral limit of direct toppling depend on the face direction only, so each column of the table sorts the lines once for all its dips. After the faces are fitted, the cost is independent of the number of points.

7. The stereonet construction​

The stereonet draws, for the face set in its properties, the construction of Dips on a lower-hemisphere net, equal-angle or equal-area. Planar sliding and flexural toppling are analysed on poles, wedge sliding on lines of intersection, and direct toppling on both, in zones they share.

ModeCurvesPrimary zone (red)Secondary zone (yellow)
Planar slidingSlope face; friction cone — the poles of planes dipping at ϕ\phi, the circle of plunge 90∘−ϕ90^\circ-\phi; daylight envelope — the poles of the planes whose dip vector lies in the face; lateral limits at αf±λp\alpha_f\pm\lambda_pPoles critical by §3.1—
Wedge slidingSlope face; friction cone — the lines plunging at ϕ\phi; friction plane — the great circle dipping ϕ\phi towards the faceLines passing Markland's testBetween the slope face and the friction plane: one-plane sliding (§3.2)
Flexural topplingSlope face; slip-limit plane — the great circle dipping ψf−ϕ\psi_f-\phi towards the face; lateral limits at αf±λt\alpha_f\pm\lambda_tPoles critical by §3.3—
Direct topplingSlope face; friction cone (plunge 90∘−ϕ90^\circ-\phi); slope angle cone — the lines as far from vertical as the face dip, plunge 90∘−ψf90^\circ-\psi_f, drawn for faces under 90∘90^\circ; lateral limits at αf±λd\alpha_f\pm\lambda_dZones 1 and 2Zone 3: oblique toppling, and oblique base planes

A point of the net lies in a zone when the zone's test holds for the vector it plots. The zones are traced by marching squares over a grid of 400 cells across the net: the test is evaluated at every node, each crossing is refined by bisection along its cell edge, and the outlines are closed into rings and filled with the even-odd rule, so a hole in a zone stays a hole. The outline lies on the true boundary to well within a cell; a corner is cut by up to half a cell, and a part of a zone narrower than a cell can be missed.

The zones are drawn for the orientations as measured. With Remove Regional Dip on, the plotted poles are rotated and would sit on zones drawn for other orientations, so the overlay is not drawn.

Intersection Scatter plots the lines of §3.2 one by one, unbinned and unweighted, each tested at its pair's own friction angle, the lower of its two sets'. Past 3000 pairs of planes it visits every kk-th pair, the smallest kk that keeps within that number. The zones are drawn for the one friction angle of the analysis, so in wedge sliding a pair with stronger joints can show non-critical dots inside the primary zone: the dots agree with the table, as the zones cannot for every pair at once. Direct toppling's test (§3.4) takes no friction angle.

8. Weighting​

Two weightings make the map percentages fairer to the way the planes were measured. Neither applies to the stereonet, which has its own Terzaghi correction about one sampling line.

8.1 Sampling bias against the face​

A plane measured on an outcrop is weighted against the face where it was measured: the face fitted at the nearest point within rr of the plane's position. With n\mathbf n the plane's normal, f\mathbf f that face's normal and c=∣n⋅f∣c = \lvert\mathbf n\cdot\mathbf f\rvert,

w=min⁡ ⁣(1c, wmax)(planes seen on the face),w=min⁡ ⁣(11−c2, wmax)(traces across the face),w = \min\!\left(\frac{1}{c},\ w_{max}\right) \quad\text{(planes seen on the face)},\qquad w = \min\!\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-c^2}},\ w_{max}\right) \quad\text{(traces across the face)},

with wmax≥1w_{max} \ge 1 the cap (default 7). The first is the bias of picking planes as surfaces on the face, which under-samples the planes the face cuts edge-on (Lato et al., 2010); the second is Terzaghi's (1965) correction for traces, which under-samples planes nearly parallel to the face. A plane with no position, or no face within rr of it, has w=1w = 1, and so does a fracture of a DFN set, which samples the rock volume rather than a face. The weights enter the bins of §4.1, so they weight every percentage, lines included (wawbw_a w_b).

8.2 Local weighting​

Points with a face are grouped into cells r/4r/4 across. For each cell, the planes of each set whose positions lie within rr of the cell's centre are counted (nn, unweighted) and tested against the cell's face, giving the local critical share PlocP_{loc} (weighted as in §8.1). The percentage written is

P=n Ploc+k Pprojn+k,P = \frac{n\,P_{loc} + k\,P_{proj}}{n + k},

where PprojP_{proj} is the set's percentage from the table of §6 and kk the number of planes at which the local share has half the say (default 10; k=0k = 0 uses the local share alone). For a pair of sets n=nanbn = \sqrt{n_a n_b}, and the pair is blended only when both sets have planes nearby. A point with no plane nearby keeps PprojP_{proj}. The map then takes the highest PP over the sets (pairs) and classifies the mode again (§4.3).

9. Factors of safety​

The factors of safety are deterministic limit-equilibrium analyses of a block on each set's mean plane: the principal axis of the orientation tensor of the set's normals. The spread of a set does not enter. Each is worked out per metre of slope in section for planar sliding and toppling, and in three dimensions for wedges.

9.1 Inputs at a point​

  • The face is the point's fitted face. A face steeper than 90∘90^\circ is taken as vertical for planar sliding and toppling, whose sections need one; a face dipping less than 0.5∘0.5^\circ is level ground, and nothing is worked out.
  • The slope height HH is the Local Relief at the point (§5.2). A point without one gets no factor.
  • The upper slope dips at ψs\psi_s in the face's direction (default 0, level).
  • Strength. Each plane's shear strength is its set's joint strength at the mean effective normal stress on the plane: Mohr-Coulomb τ=c+σntan⁡ϕ\tau = c + \sigma_n\tan\phi, or Barton-Bandis τ=σntan⁡(ϕr+JRClog⁡10(JCS/σn))\tau = \sigma_n\tan(\phi_r + \mathrm{JRC}\log_{10}(\mathrm{JCS}/\sigma_n)) (Barton & Choubey, 1977), the angle capped at 70∘70^\circ and ϕr\phi_r alone where σn≥\sigma_n \ge JCS. A set without a joint strength of its own is Mohr-Coulomb at the analysis's friction angle with c=0c = 0.
  • Loading: the rock unit weight γ\gamma (default 26 kN/m³), water γw=9.81\gamma_w = 9.81 kN/m³, a water fill fwf_w from 0 to 1, and a horizontal seismic coefficient khk_h acting out of the slope.
  • Which mechanisms form. Planar sliding is tried on a set whose mean plane dips within the planar lateral limit of the face direction, more than 0.5∘0.5^\circ and less than the face. Toppling is tried on a set whose mean plane dips into the face within the toppling lateral limit, when a block width is given. Wedges are tried on every pair of sets.

Every factor is capped at 100 — a block with no driving force has none — and the map layers at 10.

9.2 Planar sliding​

After Hoek & Bray (1981) and Wyllie & Mah (2004, ch. 6). In section, the block runs from the toe up the sliding plane, dipping ψp\psi_p, to where it meets the upper slope, or to a vertical tension crack behind the crest. Its weight WW is γ\gamma times the area of its section, and the plane's length to the crack is AA. With a crack of depth zz, filled to zw=fwzz_w = f_w z,

V=12γwzw2,U=12γwzwAV = \tfrac12\gamma_w z_w^2,\qquad U = \tfrac12\gamma_w z_w A

are the water force in the crack and the uplift on the plane, falling to nothing at the toe. The normal and driving forces are

N=W(cos⁡ψp−khsin⁡ψp)−U−Vsin⁡ψp,D=W(sin⁡ψp+khcos⁡ψp)+Vcos⁡ψp,N = W(\cos\psi_p - k_h\sin\psi_p) - U - V\sin\psi_p,\qquad D = W(\sin\psi_p + k_h\cos\psi_p) + V\cos\psi_p,

and

F=A τ(N/A)D.F = \frac{A\,\tau(N/A)}{D}.

Tension crack. With None, the plane runs out through the upper slope, which must then dip less steeply than the plane. With Critical, the crack is placed where it gives the lowest factor: 48 positions from the crest to where the plane runs out (or one slope height behind the crest, when it never does) are scanned, and the lowest is refined by golden-section search. Where the plane cannot run out, the critical crack is used whatever is chosen.

9.3 Wedge sliding​

The tetrahedral wedge that the mean planes of two sets cut from the face and the upper slope, by the vector method (Hoek & Bray, 1981, ch. 8; Priest, 1993). Its line of intersection must daylight in the face, and two mean planes within 1∘1^\circ of parallel form none, whatever the minimum wedge angle of the kinematic tests. The wedge's corners are the toe, where the two planes and the face meet, the apex where the line of intersection meets the upper slope, and the top of each plane's trace on the face, at the crest HH above the toe.

  • Trace length limit. When the longer of the two traces exceeds the longest trace, the whole wedge is scaled down so that it fits.
  • Forces. The active force is the weight W=γVwW = \gamma V_w, the seismic load khWk_h W acting horizontally along the trend of the line of intersection, and the water pressure on each plane. The water follows Hoek & Bray's fully drained wedge: a mean pressure u=fwγwHw/6u = f_w\gamma_w H_w/6 on each plane, HwH_w being the wedge's height.
  • Sliding. The active force is resolved onto the two planes' normals and the line of intersection. When both planes push back, the wedge slides on both, along the line: F=(Aaτa+Abτb)/SF = (A_a\tau_a + A_b\tau_b)/S, with SS the force along the line and each τ\tau at that plane's normal stress. When only one plane pushes back, the wedge slides on that plane alone and lifts off the other (Hocking, 1976): F=A τ/∣S∣F = A\,\tau / \lvert\mathbf S\rvert, with S\mathbf S the shear force on the plane. When neither does, the wedge lifts off both, and F=0F = 0.

The stereonet's key says which: both, 1st, 2nd or lifts.

9.4 Block toppling​

After Goodman & Bray (1976), as Wyllie & Mah (2004, ch. 9) set it out. The toppling planes are the set's mean plane, dipping into the face; the blocks between them are Δx\Delta x wide (the block width) and stand on bases square to the toppling planes, dipping ψp=90∘−δ\psi_p = 90^\circ - \delta out of the slope. The line through the blocks' feet, the stepped base, runs ψb=ψp+β\psi_b = \psi_p + \beta with β\beta the base step (default 10∘10^\circ). With the face dip ψf\psi_f and the upper slope ψs\psi_s,

a1=Δxtan⁡(ψf−ψp),a2=Δxtan⁡(ψp−ψs),b=Δxtan⁡(ψb−ψp),a_1 = \Delta x\tan(\psi_f - \psi_p),\quad a_2 = \Delta x\tan(\psi_p - \psi_s),\quad b = \Delta x\tan(\psi_b - \psi_p),

and the nn-th block from the toe is yn=n(a1−b)y_n = n(a_1 - b) high up to the crest's block and yn−1−a2−by_{n-1} - a_2 - b beyond it, until the blocks run out. The crest's block is the one at Hcos⁡(ψf−ψp)/sin⁡ψfH\cos(\psi_f-\psi_p)/\sin\psi_f along the face.

Working down from the top block, each block passes on to the one below the force it needs to be held against toppling or against sliding, whichever is greater (Wyllie & Mah, eqs. 9.17 and 9.18), or nothing when it stands. The force left at the toe says whether the slope stands. The factor of safety is the factor FF by which tan⁡ϕ\tan\phi on the bases and sides must be divided for the toe force to fall to zero: above 1 the slope stands with friction to spare. It is found by bisection in log F between 0.001 and 100 (below 0.001 reads 0, above 100 reads 100). Toppling uses the set's kinematic friction angle (§4.1) on bases and sides; cohesion plays no part. This reproduces Hoek & Bray's 16-block example at F=1.02F = 1.02.

9.5 Mapping​

Every point with a face and a relief takes, over the sets (pairs of sets), the lowest factor of each mechanism and the lowest of all, with the mechanism that gives it (on a tie: planar, wedge, then toppling). Points that share a face and a relief are worked out once. Where no set's mean plane forms a block, the point has no factor and its mode is none.

On the stereonet the same factors are worked out for the one face and the FoS Slope Height, with the critical tension crack, a level upper slope, no seismic load and no trace limit.

9.6 Probability of failure​

The probability of failure is worked out by Monte Carlo over the factors of safety of §9.1–9.5. Each of MM samples (default 200) draws, for every set:

  • its plane from a Fisher distribution about the set's mean plane, with the set's own concentration taken from its NN measured planes as axes, K=(N−1)/(N−R)K = (N-1)/(N-R), RR being the length of the sum of their unit normals turned to the mean's side. A set of one plane, or of planes all alike, keeps its mean plane. The angle from the mean is drawn by Fisher's (1953) inverse, cos⁡θ=1+ln⁡ ⁣(u+(1−u)e−2K)/K\cos\theta = 1 + \ln\!\left(u + (1-u)e^{-2K}\right)/K, and the azimuth about it evenly;
  • its friction angle — a Barton-Bandis set's residual friction angle — from a normal distribution about its value with the standard deviation given (default 2∘2^\circ), kept between 0.5∘0.5^\circ and 89∘89^\circ;
  • its cohesion (Mohr-Coulomb), scaled by a normal draw with the coefficient of variation given (default 0.25), and not below zero;

and the water fill evenly from its range. The probability of failure at a face is

Pf=100 #{samples with Fmin<1}M,P_f = 100\,\frac{\#\{\text{samples with } F_{min} < 1\}}{M},

FminF_{min} being the lowest factor over the mechanisms and sets of the sample; a sample in which no block forms counts as standing. The same is done for each mechanism alone.

All the draws come from one seed, made once per run and shared by every face, scale and object of the run, so the map is smooth and a run with the same seed gives the same result. On the maps, faces are grouped to 2∘2^\circ of dip and dip direction and heights to 5%, and each group is worked out once at its centre.

Acceptance. Each point is compared with the targets of its scale: the deterministic factor of safety (§9.5) against the FoS target, and PfP_f against the PoF target. The defaults are Read & Stacey's (2009, Table 9.9) criteria for a moderate consequence of failure: 1.1 and 25% for a bench, 1.2 and 20% inter-ramp, 1.3 and 10% overall (and for a single radius).

Sensitivity. On the stereonet, each input is moved one standard deviation either side of its value, the others held, and the lowest factor of safety worked out: a set's dip by its Fisher spread 81∘/K81^\circ/\sqrt K (the angle holding 63% of the distribution), its dip direction by that spread over the sine of its dip, its friction by its standard deviation, its cohesion by its coefficient of variation, and the water to the ends of its range. The inputs are listed by the width of their swing.

10. Assumptions and limitations​

  • Kinematic screening. The percentages ignore cohesion, water pressure, block size, persistence, spacing, roughness and external loads. A percentage says how much of a set's measured orientation distribution is kinematically free to fail, not how likely failure is.
  • Factors of safety and probability. The factors of safety are for each set's mean plane; the probability of failure adds the sets' spread, friction, cohesion and water, but not the slope height, the face, the unit weight, the block width or the seismic coefficient, and it treats the sets as independent. The slope height is the relief within the radius, not a surveyed toe-to-crest height. Wedges have no tension crack and no external force but water and seismic load; water is the crack fill or the drained-wedge pressure, not a water table.
  • Friction. A set without a joint strength of its own takes the analysis's friction angle, and the lateral limits are rules of thumb: 20∘20^\circ for planar sliding (Hoek & Bray, 1981) and 30∘30^\circ for flexural toppling (Goodman & Bray, 1976) are the usual values. Wider limits are more conservative.
  • Sets are the user's. The analysis takes the folders as given; a mixed folder mixes the percentages. Every plane of one set is paired with every plane of another, so a pair of sets forms nSnTn_S n_T intersections, not only the ones exposed together.
  • The face depends on the radius. A small radius follows benches and noise; a large one smooths them into the overall slope. Points with too few neighbours get no value.
  • Unsigned faces. A point cloud without camera-oriented normals cannot tell a face from its back, and its faces are folded to look upward, so overhangs are misread.
  • Overhangs. The criteria are defined for slopes; the vector tests simply carry them past vertical. Under a face dipping more than 90∘+ϕ90^\circ+\phi the slip-limit plane is itself past vertical, so every plane dipping into the face within the lateral limit counts as critical for flexural toppling, however gently it dips. Treat overhanging faces as a hazard in their own right rather than reading the mode from the map.
  • The stereonet plots poles. In wedge sliding and direct toppling the zones apply to lines of intersection, which the net does not plot; the key's percentages count the lines.

References​

  1. Barton, N., & Choubey, V. (1977). The shear strength of rock joints in theory and practice. Rock Mechanics, 10, 1–54.
  2. Goodman, R. E. (1980). Introduction to Rock Mechanics. Wiley, New York.
  3. Goodman, R. E., & Bray, J. W. (1976). Toppling of rock slopes. Proceedings of the Specialty Conference on Rock Engineering for Foundations and Slopes, ASCE, Boulder, Colorado, 2, 201–234.
  4. Hocking, G. (1976). A method for distinguishing between single and double plane sliding of tetrahedral wedges. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences & Geomechanics Abstracts, 13(7), 225–226.
  5. Hoek, E., & Bray, J. W. (1981). Rock Slope Engineering (3rd ed.). Institution of Mining and Metallurgy, London.
  6. Hudson, J. A., & Harrison, J. P. (1997). Engineering Rock Mechanics: An Introduction to the Principles. Pergamon, Oxford.
  7. Lato, M. J., Diederichs, M. S., & Hutchinson, D. J. (2010). Bias correction for view-limited lidar scanning of rock outcrops for structural characterization. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, 43, 615–628.
  8. Markland, J. T. (1972). A useful technique for estimating the stability of rock slopes when the rigid wedge slide type of failure is expected. Imperial College Rock Mechanics Research Report 19.
  9. Fisher, R. A. (1953). Dispersion on a sphere. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A, 217, 295–305.
  10. Priest, S. D. (1993). Discontinuity Analysis for Rock Engineering. Chapman & Hall, London.
  11. Read, J., & Stacey, P. (eds.) (2009). Guidelines for Open Pit Slope Design. CSIRO Publishing, Melbourne.
  12. Terzaghi, R. D. (1965). Sources of error in joint surveys. Géotechnique, 15(3), 287–304.
  13. Wyllie, D. C., & Mah, C. W. (2004). Rock Slope Engineering: Civil and Mining (4th ed.). Spon Press, London.
  • Slope Stability — the user guide: the dialog, the layers, the stereonet properties and troubleshooting.
  • Stereonet User Guide — plotting, contouring and grouping the orientations the analysis reads.
  • Orientation — the Orientation branch of the Interpretation tree, where the set folders live, and Auto-cluster Selected Orientations.
  • Stress Tensors — the active stress tensor's friction coefficient, from which the default friction angle is taken.